Recording Forum

[elpea117]

It would be nice to have a forum where everyone can record their music and share it with other people to see what they think, and if there is a forum where this currently goes on a lot then which one is it?

[Hawk]

Music lounge.

[elpea117]

ok thanks!!!!!!!!

[Hawk]

No problem, I'dve typed more but my recording equipment is in the way of my keyboard.

[muchavo]

actually down at guitarnoise.com

they have a forum like that its not that bad

i like it

its usefull

the music lounge here is kind of like just a place to talk about music in general

but i think that if everyone knew were to put their recordings right off the bat they would get reviews faster

for example
i posted a song today in electric guitar

is it in the wrong place?, not really, it could have gone other places, maybe improv, maybe mousic lounge

either way no body replied

why maybe because it got buried by every thing else that is put in there

and once it goes to page two, which could happen in a couple of days forget about

it would be a great addition to the forums

alot of people would get more advice about their playing because their threads wont get buried


over all it would definatly benifet everyone


agreed?

[Hawk]

Yes, you could go there whenever you felt like listening.

...


*goes to see recording*

[muchavo]

Exactly, so any one else up for this idea?

[elpea117]

wow i might have actually started something. :D

[muchavo]

i could start a list on urls of threads that could be moved

i know there are alot, of the ones i put on the list ill make sure have active links

[popmusic_sux]

We've had threads suggesting other forums before (recording, vocals, drums, lyrics, etc.) Having all those separate forums is unnecessary, they will get little to no traffic.

The Music Lounge is for "Anything and Everything Music," which encompasses all of the above topics.

If you have a recording that you want critiqued, you should put it in the Music Lounge. If there's a question about recording equipment, put it in the "Gear" forum.

Shawn has been reluctant to add separate forums in the past and I don't see any other forums being added anytime soon.

[Hawk]

Hmmm... I can see why, this site doesn't have many regs... and Splitting them up further wouldn't help the site much... But A recording Forum would really only unite threads that have been posted all over...

However, recordings aren't very common, and the forum might be useless till someone goes on a binge... BUT!!! If people started recording more because of it...

Depends how everyone reacts to it.

[MadMattUK]

All here in favour of a seperate Recording forum say "Aye"


MadMattUK: "Aye"

[Hawk]

How bout I start a poll on it?

(That's a retorical question, I'm doing it anyway.)

No, I don't know how to spell retorical... I know there's an H somewhere.

[Slash 88]

How bout I start a poll on it?

(That's a retorical question, I'm doing it anyway.)

No, I don't know how to spell retorical... I know there's an H somewhere.

yup, it's rhetorical

[muchavo]

thread continued here

http://www.guitarlodge.com/forums/guitar-bass/showthread.php?t=19580